All Skills or Not

[Vadio]

followed discussion in this topic : http://www.xsyon.com/forum/showthrea...l-craft-skills

Yes -> possible craft everything but need master system or something ( i can learn recipes here )
No-> Possible craft only your chossen and open possiblity to learn from others player recipes and skills

[ifireallymust]

Purely selfish vote from me, I'm a jack of all trades master of none type player, I love to learn at least a little of everything. I have no idea what impact each system would have in the game later on, so I just voted my preference.

[carlosfc1986]

sandbox? anyone?

[Monologue]

While I also, personally love to be able to do things solo, I believe a Jack-of-all-trades situation is nice, but, I am aware of the impact it can have on a sandbox mmo, and im also very intrigued by the idea of being able to learn from other players. Plus, having limited choices should have a good impact in the economy, and the crafting community as a whole.

But yeah, as ifire, i was a bit selfish in my choice, but I would actually love if we could mix it. Allowing for only 1 choice at char creation, and then later , either thru learning from others, a mastering system, or a mix thereof, being able to learn everything you want / need.

[Doc]

If soft cap system is in place i see no problem with having all skills.

[Kurpitsa]

You should be able to do whatever, but specialization is needed to be successful in anything. No limits to pick another skill and start training that too, however.

[bruisie159]

yes with a skill cap

[Zenmaster13]

Yes, because with skill decay, it should be very difficult to master multiple professions, however, the option should be there for the hardcore crafter. I think people are counting on the good will of other people a little too much. I would like us all to trade and share, etc., but that is not how it will work out.

[yoori]

I'll say yes.
If you'd be able to learn skills from others, every tribe member would have every skill in a week. Solo players would be stuck with what they got.

The key is to be able to master limited number of skills and how many. With limited resources we will need best quality items we can get .

[dem1urge]

followed discussion in this topic : http://www.xsyon.com/forum/showthrea...l-craft-skills

Yes -> possible craft everything but need master system or something ( i can learn recipes here )
No-> Possible craft only your chossen and open possiblity to learn from others player recipes and skills

How about both? Why not be able to craft "basic" items from every craft but "advanced" stuff has to be learned from someone else (a Master) and/or "discovered" randomly? This would, of course, mean that the Powers that Be will have to make decisions about what is considered "basic/advanced". Anyone see a downside to this? I can't think of any others myself.