Originally Posted by
Robrecht
While I'm not adverse to item decay, I think it's some prime grade A bullcrap that tools decay while there's no adequate way to replace starter tools with (low quality, easy to break) tools that DON'T require a whole bunch of other tools (either for making the tool itself or making the components for the tools).
It's currently possible for even an experienced Toolmaker to wear out the tools he needs to make replacement tools with. I know it's supposed to promote interaction and trade, but that doesn't work if some of the items needed for toolcrafting (like the infamous 'old saw blade' required for all Saws) are exceedingly rare and right now mostly in the hands of a few select tribes who aren't going to trade it to their neighbours for anything approaching a fair price.
Especially not for new characters who are unfortunate to discover that the only toolmaking recipes they have are not the ones they need to replace their current tools and their current tools wear out before they can get the recipes to make new ones.