Love the personal attacks.
But lets move on.
First I will like to comment that I already posted a detailed plan for what I would to see. Im trying to show you that there are holes in your theroy about how people can get around it. I dont see why it shouldnt hold up to people trying to show you exploits to your system.
1)Problem with your system of tribes able to lable you as a troublemaker is this.
I get 3 friends all have a tribe. You keep jumping in front of you while you are in any kinda combat. Now we can gank you take all your stuff because you are "troublemaker". Notice a problem with this?
So now you are saying a GM is going to be able to tell who is or isnt a troublemaker? Great I love that. Going to have GMs able to change how wars of tribes are done. Sounds really great.
Next is the faction loss for tribes attacking without waring first.
You are in a tribe, lets call it Shrimps. Im in DDT tribe. I follow you around while you are attacking animals and jump in the AOE. Next thing you know, you attacked without waring you have faction loss. I do this all the time like 100 times. You are now an Evil tribe.
Im not trying to be a jerk, Ive played many OPEN pvp games. UO, Shadowbane, Darkfall, tons more. I know that people will exploit the system. Darkfall is one of the worst how it has open damage attacks.